News Corp defends Serena cartoon amid global backlash

By AdNews | 11 September 2018
Mark Knight's interpretation of Serena Williams.

News Corp cartoonist Mark Knight has defended an illustration of Serena Williams that critics are likening to the racist stereotypes penned by early 20th Century Jim Crow.

In the Herald Sun, Knight drew a cartoon that showed Williams having an on-court meltdown during the US Open final and the umpire urging her opponent, eventual winner Naomi Osaka, to let the 23-time grand slam winner win.

Knight said he didn’t intend his cartoon to be commentary of gender or racial politics and instead was depicting an athlete behaving poorly on court.

He told News Corp-owned Sky News: “When you caricature somebody you take their facial features and you emphasise them.

“Serena is an amazing athlete, an African American woman and a very powerfully built woman. She’s a lot of fun to draw and I didn’t draw her with malicious racial intent.”

Knight said that cartoonists are increasingly concerned about outrage caused by depicting minority groups in certain ways.

Serena cartoon tweet.png

Serena cartoon tweet.png

The cartoon caused a massive backlash on social media, with celebrities including Aussie NBA star Ben Simmons and Harry Potter JK Rowling wading into the debate (see above).

Critics say Knight’s cartoon only reinforces historically negative stereotypes about African-American women and is akin to comedy sketches using blackface.

serena-cartoon-vs-jim-crow.png 

Mark Knight's controversial Serena Williams cartoon has been
likened to racist cartoonist Jim Crow (pictured above).

On Twitter, News Corp Australasia executive chair Michael Miller defended his colleague, saying the world has become too politically correct and that bad sportsmanship was fair game.

It’s not the first time an Australian cartoonist has been widely condemned for racist depictions of people of colour.

In 2016, Bill Leak was slammed for a cartoon that implied Indigenous fathers were alcoholics, poor parents and irresponsible, again painting a whole culture with historic and hurtful race-based stereotypes.

racist cartoon1.pngBill Leak was condemned for this depicition of an Indigenous father.

Earlier this year, Knight derided Sudanese immigrants as violent thugs, fuelling lazy right-wing stereotypes in the press.

racist cartoon 2.pngAnother Mark Knight special reinforcing racist steotypes of Sudanese immigrants.

And when Australian A-League team Melbourne Heart was acquired by Manchester City's owners – a consortium including the Abu Dhabi United Group and Chinese firms – Knight was at it again, crowbarring lazy racist stereotypes into a sports story that had absolutely nothing to do with race.

Mark Knight Melbourne City.png

Knight has a talent for finding a race-based angle where one previously didn't exist.

Australia has a long and chequered history of racism towards the Indigenous population and ethnic minorities.

Whether it is was intended or not, Knight’s cartoon has been widely condemned overseas with many arguing it reinforces a growing international perception that Australia is a country of racists, with one notable exception ...

Katie Hopkins tweet.png

Have something to say on this? Share your views in the comments section below. Or if you have a news story or tip-off, drop us a line at adnews@yaffa.com.au

Sign up to the AdNews newsletter, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter for breaking stories and campaigns throughout the day.

Read more about these related brands, agencies and people

comments powered by Disqus