Digital subscriptions were the great white hope for newspapers. But the first round of comparative stats for combined print and digital sales have arrived and suggest only The Australian is moving in the right direction.
Circulation figures for the June quarter have been released by the Audit Bureau of Circulations (ABC), alongside the first year-on-year comparisons for combined print, digital and package sales (masthead sales).
In total, the print market saw a 10.9% year-on-year decline in sales, with News Corp Australia titles dropping 9.7% in total and Fairfax 16.4%. The declines appear to mirror the two companies' strategies. News Corp has remained focused on its core print products while expanding its digital footprint. Fairfax has focused more strongly on digital.
In NSW, overall masthead figures for the Monday to Friday edition of The Sydney Morning Herald declined 14.8% year-on-year, while the Saturday edition has plummeted 18.7%. The Sun-Herald tumbled 18.8%. That suggests paid digital growth is nowhere near sufficient at present to balance out print circulation decline.
In Victoria, the story for Fairfax is considerably less bleak, but is still in the negative territory. The Age Monday to Friday edition saw its combined print, digital and package sales drop 6.9%, with Saturday masthead sales falling 9.6% and the Sunday Age declining 5.4%.
The declines in masthead sales are not as steep as the declines in print-only sales, indicating digital sales are making some inroads.
Year-on-year masthead figures are only available for Fairfax titles, as News Corp did not start providing combined print and digital statistics until September 2012. However, The Australian looks like it could buck the downwards trend. While the title's print circulation declined 9.8% year-on-year in the June quarter, the title's masthead sales figures have been steadily increasing over the last few months.
Since it began providing data in September 2012, masthead sales have increased from 154,697 in the September quarter to 164,439 in the June period. The Australian's figures for the June quarter stood at 113,226 in print only, 47,784 digital only subscribers and 3,429 packaged. That compares to 121,097 print only sales for The SMH, with 22,589 digital only subscribers and 20,602 packaged.
Looking to print-only circulation figures, the results in the June quarter were particularly bleak. Not a single newspaper recorded positive growth, and across News Corp and Fairfax the best result was a 6.8% decline recorded by Fairfax's weekday edition of The Australian Financial Review. The strongest result across the whole market was recorded by West Australian Newspapers' West Australian, with a 3.8% drop.
Fairfax's Sydney Morning Herald experienced the largest print decline, sliding 17%.
Newspaper inserted magazines also saw major declines across the board, with all audited titles seeing circulation drops. The total NIMs market fell 12%.
Sign up to the AdNews newsletter, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter for breaking stories and campaigns throughout the day.
Have something to say? Send us your comments using the form below or contact the writer at firstname.lastname@example.org